As far as "local guys" (and some people who used to wrestle on the
local indies):

 49. Jerry Lynn
 67. X-Pac
200. Adam Pearce
292. Lenny Lane
401. Eric Priest

Here's how the rest of the "best of the indies" ranked:

 65. Christopher Daniels
102. Reckless Youth
159. Mike Modest
195. Air Paris
199. A.J. Styles

And here's the whole list:

1. Kurt Angle
2. Steve Austin
3. Chris Benoit
4. Keiji Muto
5. Booker T.
6. Triple H
7. Scott Steiner
8. Mitsuharu Misawa
9. Chris Jericho
10. Rhyno
11. The Undertaker
12. Genichiro Tenryu
13. Lance Storm
14. The Rock
15. El Hijo Del Santo
16. Kane
17. Jeff Hardy
18. Toshiaki Kawada
19. Diamond Dallas Page
20. Edge
21. Dr. Wagner Jr.
22. Matt Hardy
23. Minoru Tanaka
24. Jeff Jarrett
25. Jushin Thunder Liger
26. Hector Garza
27. Yoshihiro Tajiri
28. Mike Awesome
29. Christian
30. Buh-Buh Ray Dudley
31. Hurricane Helms
32. Albert
33. Nicho El Millonario (Psichosis)
34. Kazuyuki Fujita
35. Steve Corino
36. D-Von Dudley
37. Test
38. Billy Kidman
39. Jun Akiyama
40. Hugh Morrus
41. Kensuke Sasaki
42. Chavo Guerrero Jr.
43. Sean O'Haire
44. Tokyo Magnum
45. Bradshaw
46. Silver King
47. Shinya Hashimoto
48. Vader
49. Jerry Lynn
50. Eddie Guerrero
51. Hardcore Holly
52. Yuji Nagata
53. Raven
54. Juventud Guerrera
55. Taiyo Kea
56. Faarooq
57. Sabu
58. Masato Tanaka
59. Rob Van Dam
60. Chuck Palumbo
61. William Regal
62. Spike Dudley
63. Masa Chono
64. Vilanno III
65. Christopher Daniels
66. Perry Saturn
67. X-Pac
68. Jinsei Shinzaki
69. Electro Shock
70. Steve Blackman
71. Scott Norton
72. The Big Show
73. Shima Nobunaga
74. Crash Holly
75. Super Delphin
76. Tiger Mask IV
77. Satanico
78. Tommy Dreamer
79. Justin Credible
80. Manabu Nakanishi
81. Bull Buchanan
82. Shocker
83. Steve Williams
84. Hiroyoshi Tenzan
85. Satoshi Kojima
86. Grandmaster Sexay
87. Brock Lesnar
88. Scotty Too Hotty
89. Atlantis
90. The Goodfather
91. Crowbar
92. Shannon Moore
93. Shinjiro Otani
94. Super Crazy
95. Octagon
96. Chris Candido
97. Rikishi
98. Scott Hall
99. Al Snow
100. Tatsuhito Takaiwa
101. Taka Michinuko
102. Reckless Youth
103. Sho Funaki
104. La Parka
105. Scoot Andrews
106. Haku
107. The Sandman
108. Naoya Ogawa
109. Negro Casas
110. Rick Steiner
111. Dean Malenko
112. C.W. Anderson
113. Blue Panther
114. Kid Kash
115. Hiroshi Hase
116. Mike Rotunda
117. Essa Rios
118. Danny Doring
119. Mark Jindrak
120. Ricky Marvin
121. Charlie Haas
122. Akira Taue
123. Shawn Stasiak
124. Joey Matthews
125. Billy Gunn
126. Dick Togo
127. Val Venis
128. Christian York
129. Great Sasuke
130. Russ Haas
131. K-Kwik
132. Mike Quackenbush
133. Disqo
134. Black Warrior
135. Johnny Smith
136. Roadkill
137. Steven Richards
138. Minoru Fujita
139. Mike Barton
140. Tazz
141. Guido Maritato
142. Villano IV
143. 2 Cold Scorpio
144. Steven Bradley
145. D'Lo Brown
146. Gedo
147. Nova
148. Chris Kanyon
149. Takehiro Murahama
150. Buff Bagwell
151. Jado
152. Mike Rapada
153. Shelton Benjamin
154. Ultimo Guerrero
155. Villano V
156. Balls Mahoney
157. Shark Boy
158. Gran Hamada
159. Mike Modest
160. Dragon Kid
161. The Blue Boy
162. Kendo Ka Shin
163. El Felino
164. Chad Collyer
165. Jerry Lawler
166. Rey Bucanero
167. Mark Henry
168. Evan Karagias
169. Gran Naniwa
170. Low-Ki
171. Tarzan Boy
172. Julio Dinero
173. New Jack
174. Simon Diamond
175. The Maestro
176. Donvan Morgan
177. Mr. Niebla
178. Joey Abs
179. Lash LeRoux
180. Gillberg
181. Akira Nogami
182. Nick Dinsmore
183. David Flair
184. Flash
185. Brian Adams
186. Fuerza Guerrera
187. Tatsumi Fujinami
188. Bryan Clarke
189. Rico Constantino
190. Mikey Whipwreck
191. Lance Cade
192. El Dandy
193. Dusty Rhodes
194. Ekmo
195. Air Paris
196. Tony Kozina
197. Kimo
198. Rey Misterio Jr.
199. A.J. Styles
200. Adam Pearce
201. Jayson Reign
202. Gary Steele
203. Osamu Nishimura
204. El Samurai
205. Michelle Starr
206. The American Dragon
207. Nuevo Gran Apolo
208. Spanky
209. Naomichi Marufiji
210. Jet Jaguar
211. Johnny Moss
212. Jamie Knoble
213. Takao Omori
214. Trailer Park Trash
215. Damien 666
216. Yoshinari Ogawa
217. Randy Orton
218. Savio Vega
219. Rodrageous
220. Masa Fuchi
221. Tsubasa
222. Emilo Charles Jr.
223. Don Montoya
224. Jason Lee
225. Jim Steele
226. Takuma Sano
227. Ricky Banderas
228. Boyce LeGrande
229. Vic Capri
230. Kronus
231. Samu
232. Halloween
233. Andy Anderson
234. Billy Fives
235. Pete Gas
236. Tom Brandi
237. Jack Dupp
238. Romeo Bliss
239. Shinya Makabe
240. Dr. Cerebro
241. The Messiah
242. Silky Boom Boom
243. Dennis Gregory
244. Beau James
245. Tony Jones
246. Supreme
247. Glen Osbourne
248. Masai Irinara
249. K.C. Thunder
250. Otto Schwanz
251. Vincenzo Massaro
252. Damien Steele
253. Eric Angle
254. Jon Ryan
255. Mike Shane
256. Todd Shane
257. Leviathan
258. Onyx
259. Koji Kanemoto
260. Frank Parker
261. Horace Hogan
262. Eddie Golden
263. J.R. Ryder
264. Major DeBeers
265. King Kong Bundy
266. Mike Sullivan
267. Roger Anderson
268. Vance Nevada
269. Cham Pain
270. Vic Grimes
271. Race Steele
272. Jason Jett
273. Andre Baker
274. Kis Kaos
275. Jag
276. Adm Firestorm
277. Col. Boomer Payne
278. David Young
279. Inferno
280. Jeremy Lopez
281. The Prototype
282. Jason Rumble
283. Corporal Punishment
284. Rob Conway
285. Lex Lovett 
286. Matt Stryker
287. Robert Thompson
288. John Rambo
289. Blade Boudreaux
290. Shorty Smalls
291. Mikey Henderson
292. Lenny Lane
293. Trent Acid
294. Pogo The Clown
295. Hotstuff Hernandez
296. Shane Ballard
297. Lodi
298. Shannon Ballard 
299. Chris Nelson
300. Steve Sharp
301. J.C. Dazz
302. Jon Heidenreich
303. Kevin Northcutt 
304. Chilly Willy
305. Vito DeNucci
306. Steve Boz
307. Jimmy Rave
308. Brandon K.
309. John Phoenix
310. Scottie Wren
311. L.A. Smooth
312. Cody Hawk
313. Naphtali
314. Samoa Joe
315. Prince Nana
316. Scott Bishop
317. Caprice Coleman
318. Robbie Royce
319. Frankie Kazarian
320. Jason Justice
321. Preston Quinn
322. Qenaan Creed
323. The Damaja 
324. Matt Murphy
325. J.J. Johnston
326. Quinn Magnum
327. Iceman
328. Rob McBride
329. Rick Deezel
330. Keiji Sakota
331. Johnny Kashmere
332. Biggie Biggs
333. T. Rantula
334. Mr. Ooh La La
335. Drake Dawson
336. Dean Champion
337. Dusty Wolfe
338. Curtis Thomson
339. Ricky Harrison
340. Ty Street
341. Rico Casanova
342. Lord Zoltan
343. Skull Ganz
344. Rick Fuller
345. Ace Darling
346. Lazz
347. Bart Sawyer
348. Nathan Jones
349. Rory Fox
350. Moondog Molsonn
351. Dr. Luther
352. Boom Boom Comini
353. Dylan Night
354. Stone Mountain 
355. Scott D'Amore
356. Hardkore Kidd
357. Jacey North
358. Rapid Fire Maldonado
359. Vinnie Capelli
360. Seven
361. 2-Dope
362. Barry Horowitz
363. Bull Schmitt
364. Ronnie Vegas
365. Moondog Wenzel
366. Afa Jr.
367. Mentallo
368. Sydeswype
369. Bad Boy Basil
370. Terry Allen
371. Cheetah Master
372. Marc Ash 
373. Bruiser Bennett
374. The Bruiser
375. Chris Michaels
376. Vince Goodnite
377. Smelly
378. Maxx Justice
379. Juda Young
380. Piranah
381. Trooper Gilmore
382. T.J. Powers
383. John Balsamo
384. Dino Divine
385. Horseshu
386. Kid U.S.A.
387. Vince Kaplack
388. Shirley Doe
389. Rich Myers
390. Johnny Spade
391. Bobo Brazil Jr.
392. Crusher Hansen
393. Juggernaut
394. Darren Dalton
395. The Bouncer
396. J-Rocc
397. Creeping Death
398. Monsta Mack
399. Beau Douglas
400. Mafia
401. Eric Priest
402. Jardi Frantz
403. Robbie Rage
404. Guillotine LeGrande
405. Brian Anthony
406. Adam Booker
407. Paul Vault
408. Miyaki Frantz
409. Dapper Dan
410. Steve Southern
411. Masked Maniac
412. Scab
413. Dave Johnson
414. Paul Diamond
415. Zak Mason
416. Kevin Knight
417. Johnny Malibu
418. Poison
419. Major Havoc
420. Bobby Rogers
421. J.T. Lightning
422. David Lee Gilbert
423. Badd Brad
424. Ralph Mosca
425. The Persian Prince
426. Chris Krueger
427. Al Savage
428. L.A. Wild One
429. Jeff Roth
430. Danny Rose
431. Sebastian Kane
432. Mozart Fontaine
433. Johnny Graham
434. Earl The Pearl
435. Super Destroyer 2000
436. Guy Williams
437. Boogie Woogie Brown
438. Jeff Hammerick
439. Reverend Slim
440. Bob Evans
441. Ronnie Zukko
442. Shawn Christopher
443. Brian Danzig
444. Seijin Akki
445. Red
446. Joey Corman
447. Jake Damien
448. Alex Arion
449. Don Basher
450. Juan Xavier
451. Dave Greco
452. Chic White
453. Metal Maniac
454. Nova Cain
455. The California Kid
456. Joel Maximo
457. Indiana Kidd Jr.
458. B.J. Whitmer
459. Bob Keller
460. Jose Maximo
461. Jimmy Snuka Sr.
462. Brody Hawk
463. Austin James
464. Homeless Jimmy
465. Brian Bedlam
466. Mark Mest
467. Flex Fenom
468. Tommy Idol
469. Dave Sherman
470. Jon Douglas
471. Adam Jacobs
472. Rick Noble
473. Rod Bell
474. Jimmie Lee
475. Kyle Storm
476. Benny Stoltzfus
477. Gino Martino
478. Majik
479. Chris Charger
480. Terry Knight
481. Brandon Walker
482. C.B. Cane
483. The Japanese Pool Boy
484. Joe Brock
485. Hadrian
486. Ash Parker
487. Bulldozer Benton
488. Ben Galvan
489. Thornn
490. Mack Truck
491. Osiris
492. J.W. Boss
493. The Hussla
494. Jeff Starr
495. Superstar Steve
496. Dango Wynn
497. Sean Royal
498. Supreme Lee Great
499. Bill Mudd
500. Pepper Parks